Flash drive Comparison: Corsair Flash Voyager GTX, Kingston DataTraveler Max, Sandisk Ultra USB-C, Sandisk Extreme Pro
9 February 2022, Comments: 2

 February 2022         Ian Chiu

We put five USB 3.2 drives from Corsair, Kingston, and Sandisk to test.  They all come from reliable brands that have been in the flash drive business since the inception of the product category.  And for the purpose of the article, we picked drives that strike a balance between form factor and performance.

But for those of you who value form factor over speed, mini USB drives serve well as semi-permanent storage for your laptops.  Likewise, if you need a drive for data exchange between USB-C and legacy USB ports, dual-headed flash drives are just what you need but speeds don’t match the ones featured here.

What is the Best Flash Drive?


Assuming you have the right port (i.e. USB 3.2 Gen 2×1) to match, the Kingston DataTraveler Max provides a great performance-to-price ratio and hence makes the most sense for power users.  Its performance stands head and shoulders above nearly all competitors and is one of the fastest thumb drives given its form factor.  You will find the drive quite handy when you need to do a system recovery and run / install Windows on a flash drive.  The drive also comes with a retractable USB-C connector and five years of warranty.  Through an optional USB-A to USB-C adapter, it maintains backward compatibility with legacy USB-A ports.   For its intended purpose, the DataTraveler Max has earned our recommendation.

Feature Comparison


Corsair Flash Voyager GTX
Corsair
Flash Voyager GTX

See it on Amazon
$78.16 for 256GB
Kingston DataTraveler Max
Kingston
DataTraveler Max

See it on Amazon
$47.99 for 256GB
Kingston DataTraveler 80
Kingston
DataTraveler 80

See it on Amazon
$47.87 for 256GB
Sandisk Ultra USB-C
Sandisk
Ultra USB-C

See it on Amazon
$29.62 for 256GB
Sandisk Extreme Pro
Sandisk
Extreme PRO

See it on Amazon
$59.99 for 256GB
Connector:USB-AUSB-CUSB-CUSB-CUSB-A
Storage:128GB - 1TB256GB - 1TB32 - 256GB32 - 256GB256GB - 1TB
Interface(s):USB 3.2 Gen 1 (5Gbps)USB 3.2 Gen 2 (10Gbps)USB 3.2 Gen 1 (5Gbps)USB 3.2 Gen 1 (5Gbps)USB 3.2 Gen 1 (5Gbps)
UASP?YesYesNoNoNo
Movie Read:
(10GB MP4)
392.42MB/s725.08MB/s196.47MB/s149.72MB/s283.76MB/s
Movie Write:
(10GB MP4)
134.38.MB/s552.52MB/s34.52MB/s22.82MB/s224.88MB/s
Photo Read:
(5GB JPEGs)
305.08MB/s527.08MB/s171.09MB/s133.35MB/s213.04MB/s
Photo Write:
(5GB JPEGs)
103.76MB/s364.49MB/s27.32MB/s12.38MB/s121.81MB/s
Retractable Connector?NoYesNoYesYes
Dimensions:78 x 26.4 x 10.8mm82.2 x 22 x 9mm42.2 x 15 x 6.7mm59.4 x 12.6 x 8.6mm71 x 21 x 11mm
Build Material:Zinc alloyPlasticPlastic ends with aluminum alloy bodyPlasticPlastic body with aluminum alloy
Color(s):BlackBlackSilverBlackBlack
Software:NoneNoneNoneSanDisk SecureAccess, RescuePROSanDisk SecureAccess, RescuePRO
Release Date:Jan 2015Aug 2021July 2020Jan 2020Jan 2017
Warranty:5 years5 years5 years5 yearsLifetime

Pricing is last updated by Amazon on 2022-05-20 at 04:00.  When you buy through Amazon affiliate links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.

Benchmark Analysis


Our tests were carried out on Nodesoft’s DiskBench on 2019 MacBook Pro with 10Gbps USB-C ports.  Note that having USB-C onboard has nothing to do with the speed of the drives.  A USB-C thumb drive can be sold as a USB 3.2 Gen 1 (5Gbps) or USB 3.2 Gen 2×1 (10Gbps) storage device.

From the graph below, Kingston DataTraveler Max’s impressive transfer speeds clearly put the drive ahead of the competition in our 10GB MP4 file benchmark.  Still, it’s best to keep in mind that the Max is USB 3.2 Gen 2 (10Gbps) – capable of delivering 900MB/s – with ideal PC specs while others reviewed here are limited by their USB 3.2 Gen 1 interface (5Gbps).

Bar chart showing USB speeds between Corsair Flash Voyager GTX, Kingston DataTraveler Max, DataTraveler 80, Sandisk Ultra USB-C, and Extreme Pro.

Our only caveat was that the drive started to throttle after the 20GB mark during a 40GB write endurance test on our 256GB unit.  We witnessed speeds dropping to 80MB/s from 550MB/s.  The reason behind this could be the drive’s lack of a proper thermal solution with firmware caps kicking in to avoid the drive from overheating.  Running out of SLC cache during sequential write for such a large file could also be the cause of throttling.

Corsair Flash Voyager GTX – essentially an SSD coupled with a USB 3.0 to SATA controller – didn’t suffer from the same throttling issue during this endurance test.  Due to the SATA limitation and 5Gbps USB-A interface, GTX’s overall speeds were no match against the DataTraveler Max.  It’s also worth noting that the GTX – like Kingston’s Max – is both USAP- and TRIM-enabled, meaning the drive is basically an SSD in a thumb drive form factor and should excel in IO-intensive tasks.

Also included in our benchmark involved copying back and forth a thousand JPEGs totaling 4.7GB between the flash drives and our laptop. This test confirmed the level of performance you can expect when transferring small files in bulk.  Keep in mind manufacturers usually don’t advertise benchmarks for small file-sized operations so your mileage may vary.  So, for our test units, we saw the DataTraveler Max continued to lead by a sizeable margin.  The Sandisk Extreme Pro delivered all-around performance via legacy USB-A.  We simply included the Kingston DataTraveler 80 and Sandisk Ultra USB-C in the benchmark graph for the sake of comparison.

 Design & Build


Design-wise, the Corsair Flash Voyager GTX’s zinc alloy body adds to its toughness as well as weight.  It is clearly built to take a beating, suffice to say.  The flash drive should be able to easily survive after a drop or after being run over by a vehicle occasionally.  Our only gripe with the chassis is that it’s very prone to scratches which make the drives lose some of their appeals over time.  It’s worth mentioning that the Corsair has a wider-than-normal profile which poses a problem in accessing horizontally adjacent ports.  Corsair opts for a removable metallic cap that fits snugly with the drive’s USB plug – thanks to the cap’s rubber seal interior.

In contrast to the Corsair, Kingston DataTraveler Max is an all-plastic affair.  We had hoped Kingston opts for more premium building materials that add durability to the drive’s body.   The unit comes with a retractable USB-C plug as well as a keychain loophole.  In terms of size, the DataTraveler Max is slimmer and lighter than the Flash Voyager GTX.  It is significantly wider than other USB-C drives reviewed here.  Hence, plugging the DataTraveler Max into a laptop will likely block access to a neighboring port if there’s one.  Its smaller sibling – DataTraveler 80 – is also a USB-C flash drive that is encased in an aluminum alloy body for added protection.

Moving onto Sandisk’s offerings, the contoured-shaped Extreme Pro goes with the company’s tried-and-true USB slider mechanism with an outer shell that is made of aluminum alloy to improve its durability.  The minimalist Ultra USB-C drive, however, is built with flimsy plastic material and its slide-out connector mechanism leaves something to be desired.  iPad users may want to know the Sandisk Ultra USB-C is the only flash drive featured here that will directly plug into a compatible USB-C iPad with a case on.  For other drives, a USB-C to USB-A adapter or a USB-C dock might not be the most elegant solution but works without a noticeable performance penalty.

 Best Deals Online


Pricing is last updated by Amazon on 2022-05-20 at 04:00.  When you buy through Amazon affiliate links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.


USB Duplicators By Nexcopy
Nexcopy manufactures a variety of PC-based and standalone USB duplicator solutions.

PC based systems support advanced USB functions such as write protection, CD-ROM partition and multi-partition creation, while standalone systems are ultra-fast, high speed USB copiers duplicating gigabytes of data quickly and accurately.


2 responses on “Best USB 3.2 Flash Drives for Portable Backup & File Transfer

  1. Patrick DM Outhier says:

    I will stick with my Kanguru FlashTrust or SS3 its not as fast but it has a write protect switch.