December 2019 Ian Chiu
We put five 128GB mini USB drives from Kingston, Lexar, PNY, Samsung and Sandisk to test. These compact drives by design can always stay plugged as a semi-permanent storage, yet fast enough for everyday tasks.
If performance is above all else, Lexar JumpDrive S47 and Samsung FIT Plus are the ones to go for as they come out on top in comparison to other mini USB drives in our tests. The S47, however, has an edge over the FIT Plus when it comes to write performance whereas the FIT Plus is faster in sequential read. But if you’re looking for a massive 512GB, then only the Samsung and PNY offer it. For the budget conscious, either drive’s cost per gigabyte is also reasonably low considering its zippy performance. Perhaps our only complaint is the FIT Plus’s size being noticeably larger than the JumpDrive S47. The Lexar is is backed by a 3-year warranty whereas the Samsung is protected by a 5-year warranty.
FIT Plus USB 3.1
Ultra Fit 3.1
|Storage:||16 - 128GB||32 - 256GB||32 - 512GB||32 - 256GB||16 - 512GB|
|Interface:||USB 3.1 Gen 1||USB 3.1 Gen 1||USB 3.1 Gen 1||USB 3.1 Gen 1||USB 3.1 Gen 1|
|Dimensions:||25 x 12.2 x 4.5mm||17.3 x 15 x 7.45mm||20.8 x 15.2 x 6.4mm||23.6 x 18.8 x 7.37mm||19.1 x 15.9 x 8.8mm|
|Build Material:||Aluminum body||Plastic grip, aluminum body||Plastic grip, aluminum body||Plastic grip, aluminum body||Plastic body|
|June 2015||Oct 2019||Aug 2016||June 2018||Jan 2018|
|Warranty:||5 years||3 years||1 year||5 years||5 years|
Our large file (10GB MP4) transfer tests have proved that the Samsung’s FIT Plus was an undisputed leader in sequential read and that the Lexar’s second generation mini drive – JumpDrive S47 – was the best in write performance. Our other test, which involved copying back and forth 5GB JPEGs (most of them being between 4 and 8MB), revealed similar results showing Lexar and Samsung outperforming others.
It’s also worth noting that Samsung’s performance ratings vary between different capacities. The 32GB and 64GB model can reach up to 200MB/s whereas the 128GB and 256GB version can do 300MB/s. Lexar claims its drive can hit 250MB/s which is pretty close to what our S47 achieved in this benchmark. Lastly, we noticed the Sandisk exhibited performance inconsistencies during write operations. Our Ultra Fit would actually drop to below 10MB/s before slowly returning to above 30MB/s. The same thing didn’t happen with the other drives we’ve tested.
Note these two tests focused primarily on sequential performance, because we felt most people would rely on a mini drive primarily as intermediary or secondary storage for media data. These mini drives, without a decent flash controller, are inherently incapable of handling applications that require fast random access. For this reason, we didn’t bother with additional testing.
The featured low-profile USB drives are all similarly small, but as soon as they are put next to each other, the Lexar JumpDrive S47’s diminutive size compares favorably to others – even if only by a fraction. When inserted, the Lexar only protrudes just 5mm from the edge of a laptop as shown in the picture below. This makes the drive easily a no-brainer choice for an add-on drive for semi-permanent storage on your laptop. The second best performer – Samsung FIT Plus – in comparison is noticeably larger, probably in favor of heat dissipation. All but Lexar have a keyring loop hole, if you need one.
In terms of durability, Sandisk took a step backward with its squishy plastic connector with latest version of Ultra Fit 3.1. This is a concern that is already echoed by a number of user reviews on Amazon. Having said that, if you intend to leave the drive plugged at all times, this shouldn’t be that big of a problem. We would have to say the other drives with their metal USB connectors protecting the flash components could likely survive if being stepped on.
Buyers who want a drive that only protrudes as little as possible from a USB port should consider one. Thumb drives in general stick out quite conspicuously so they could easily get bent when being bumped repeatedly. This could easily result in data loss and maybe even worse, a broken USB port.
By design, compact drives can always stay inserted to a USB-enabled car stereo or to a notebook as a semi-permanent storage for media. They can also free up precious space on the laptop’s speedy SSD for mission critical tasks. For this reason, a mini USB drive can actually prove to be quite practical to some of us who might need an effortless storage expansion option.